How do you track recipe alterations?

Not very well, to be honest. If it’s a recipe I make very often, it will eventually become habit. One-off swap outs of ingredients are easier, since this will be triggered by my personal preference or accessibility of certain ingredients. But a subtler switch is hard for me to remember, especially with online recipes.

Every once in a while I like to make a classic braised beef brisket with daikon in the Instapot, and I prepped the beef tendon with the same online recipe I used last time. I completely forgot that their recommendation makes the beef tendon waaaaay too soft (like falling apart soft). Everything else about the recipe is great, but they must all like mushy tendon.

1 Like

Not an answer but to the OP @firthh ; how are you currently keeping your recipes? Paper, app, digital? That seems to make a lot of difference.

2 Likes

Digital - I’m a software developer so I’ve been cobbling together my own solution because I couldn’t find something that worked the way I wanted it to. Still figuring out if it’s just me or if others have the same problem.

I see. I’d love to see or hear about what you have come up with.

I use Paprika, which allows for notes.

It’s easy to import recipes from most sites, and I copy and paste those I can’t, or take pictures of those I still have on paper. I still use the ones on paper from time to time, including the recipe pictured here.

I’ve had that paper recipe for 20+ years, and experiment with the frosting cocoa percentage each year.

Come to think of it, I probably keep most of my notes here on Hungry Onion!

2 Likes

Like others have said (if I actually remember to so), I just dump a given recipe into a Word or (free) Libre Office doc, attribute the original recipe, then note how I have deviated from the original.

I try to keep the original then use italics and/or yellow highlights to show where I’ve, um “improved” the original recipe.

2 Likes

I like copy me that for saving and modifying recipes.

I’m new here so I can’t post links. The website is cookbook(dot)directory
If you find a recipe, there is a ‘view history’ button that takes you to a page where you can see different revisions for a recipe. I store the entire recipe each time a change is made so you can compare them
There’s a lot more that I could do to but it’s really just me using it right now

1 Like

As others have noted: I write in my cookbooks, either directly on the page if I’m confident about my edits, or on a post-it note if the changes are a work in progress (eg what to change next time). I have NYT Cooking and sometimes do private notes there. Usually, though, I make notes within Recipe Keeper, the app that I use to store and organize all my online recipes. For example, here are my notes on this SK recipe:

“1 package ground turkey = 2x meatballs. Baked extras 15’ at 400. Make meatballs SMALL so they’re easier to eat. Spinach wasn’t good in this.”

3 Likes