Spinal Tap II: The End Continues (2025) - dir. Rob Reiner
The original This is Spinal Tap (1984) was huge surprise to audiences. The high-wire act of improvising an entire film, with only a rough story outline to go off, was thrilling to watch as a fact by itself. That it was being done so masterfully, to a result that is arguably one of the funniest movies ever (I put it up there with Young Frankenstein and Duck Soup, among others.) was kind of mind-blowing. This, of course, led to Guest, McKean, and Shearer launching a whole series of films (A Mighty Wind, Best in Show, et al) made with the same method.
To attempt a sequel to the film with that sort of lighting-in-a-bottle energy is risky. The danger is great of the entire thing turning into an exercise in nostalgia. “Hey! Remember all the weird ‘dead drummer’ stories? Let’s do a few of those!” I admit, I was dreading the moment when Nigel would announce that his new amplifier now goes to 12. Thankfully, that moment never came.
To be sure, there ARE some pure “hey, remember…” moments. There are more dead drummer stories, and they’re.. ok, but frankly, among the weaker jokes. But some of the gags are genuinely hilarious, like the stage crew putting up a video of the Cooper’s Hill Cheese-Rolling and Wake, a reference to the original trailer for the movie, where Guest & Co. spoof it.
The premise of the film is that after the events captured in 1984 in Marty DiBergi’s documentary, the band continued to tour together until 2009, when the two core members, David St. Hubbins and Nigel Tufnel, suddenly stopped speaking and abruptly ended the band, seemingly for good. But the daughter of their deceased manager, who inherited the band’s contract, found they owed her one final concert. So DiBergi has returned to document the band’s reunion and preparation for a big, star-studded final show in New Orleans.
Meeting the characters again is instantly funny, because in grand elder-rocker tradition, they have all maintained their terrible 80’s hairstyles, even as they have gone grey, paunchy and wrinkled, which they make absolutely no effort to hide. The chemistry between Guest, McKean, and Shearer is still there and still works, though, as you might expect, things have slowed down a bit with the passing of the years. These guys are still funnier than 99% of the people on the planet, but they’re all nearly 80. There are a number of fun cameos, both from folks reprising their roles from the first film and a number of real-life musicians playing themselves. In particular, we’re treated to Tap performing with Paul McCartney and Elton John.
Is this as funny as the original? No. Of course not. But then, almost nothing could be. However, it’s a lovely way to put a little bow around this world that doesn’t grate or make you angry the way, say, the last couple of chapters of Indiana Jones did. And, finally, we get to see the Stonehenge prop in all its glory.
3 out of 5 foil wrapped cucumbers.