I guess this is what happens when a place starts resting on their laurels a bit too much. Our lunch at Casa Mexico, which is affiliated with South Philly Barbacoa, was a massive letdown.
We’d been here a couple of times before, but clearly I’d forgotten just how mediocre our latest experience a couple of years ago was. As had been the case on our previous visits, they were out of their ”famous” carnitas. Again . Strike #1
The lunch deal of 3 tacos for $13 sounded like a great option for us to sample (almost) Everything But The Carnitas, and we each were going to get a variety — chorizo, bistec & camarones para mí, pibil, pollo & fish for para el. No es posible. Gotta order 3 of the same Strike #2
Left with only 2 choices out of about 10, my pic chose the pibil, I got the camarones — naively envisioning something akin to the amazing Cajun shrimp tacos from my favorite taco slinger in >cough, cough< Central PA.
That vision was shattered by the appearance of my plate. Each taco held 2 tiny, heavily battered shrimp, plain shredded red cabbage, and a few random pomegranate arils.
The shrimp had no flavor whatsoever, and no amount of hot sauce (a red & green salsa with a small plate of corn chips is served as a free snack) could save them. No detectable seasoning, not even salt. Strike #3
While the pibil tacos were far more generous with the amount of pork, they were unfortunately almost as bland as the shrimp & needed salt as well — tho at least they weren’t as dry.
The house-made corn tortillas might be the first I ever had anywhere that didn’t fall apart almost immediately. Both plates had near desiccated radish and cuke slices on them.
Finally, when I went to wash my hands after our meal, one of the stalls / toilets was in such a condition I was glad I didn’t need to use them. Strike #4
The total with tip came to almost $45, which is more than any of this was worth, and I was genuinely pissed for spending that kind of money on such an absolute disappointment
Our server was incredibly friendly, but even a saint couldn’t save this experience. I will absolutely never return & cannot in good faith recommend anyone else does, either. Shoulda split a banh mi from Ba Le instead
Hopefully, our celebratory dinner tonight will be better. Low bar at least