I’ve had a lot of Tillamook products including their Sharp Cheddar but not their Extra Sharp Cheddar. I’ll give it a try next time I go shopping. There’s also a Tillamook Maker’s Reserve 2018 Extra Sharp White Cheddar that I’ve seen at Safeway and been tempted to buy but haven’t yet.
My latest cheddar find is Wyke Farms Aged Mature and Sharp Cheddar. I really like the flavor of that one. It’s an English import that I found at Walmart, and it’s fairly inexpensive. I also noticed the Walmart is carrying Cathedral City Mature English Cheddar. I’ve bought that and Cathedral City Extra Mature at Safeway and enjoy those, too.
My latest purchase from Safeway is Snowdonia Black Bomber, another cheddar from the UK. I haven’t tried it, yet. It’s more expensive than the others I’ve mentioned. Hope it’s worth the $.
