Nicholas Creamery Monmouth county

They actually have a video on their Instagram showing them dumping a pie into the base!

1 Like

Yep, churn baby churn!

1 Like

I had the cranberry walnut the other day. Was good but would have been better with goat cheese ice cream

1 Like

Funny, when I read that flavor I thought the same thing!

1 Like

I bought a pint of the cranberry walnut and plan to use it as an ice cream cake filling once I bake an orange poundcake loaf.

1 Like

YUUUUUUUUUUUM (these are many of my favorite flavors!)

1 Like

Us too. Holiday fav.

1 Like

For those who aren’t following NC on social media, they just announced they have BASIL ice cream today. One of my favorite chefs (Zod Arafai, formerly of Blu in Montclair) used to make basil gelato every summer and I consumed huge bowls of it each year.
I’ll be near an NC location on Wednesday and am already planning. Talercio’s rainbow cookie ice cream and now Basil. In separate cups. :slight_smile:

6 Likes

I may just have to stop by the new Wall location one of these days.

2 Likes

Basil. Delicious, but as always, I’d want even more basil flavor. That said, the scoop was full of flecks of basil, and full spoonfuls had far more flavor than the tasting spoon did.

3 Likes

That is my problem with Nicholas. I find the flavors need to be more pronounced and/or more evenly distrubited through the scoop.

2 Likes

Yeah, I think many HOs would agree - we’re willing to go bolder! That said, their ice cream is still DELICIOUS. I was bummed that the container of Talercio’s rainbow cookie collab was down to the bottom/sides and didn’t want a scraping - next time! But they still have the black raspberry/choc chunk which was awesome.

2 Likes

Mr Bean has been on this pistachio kick - their’s is delicious!

1 Like


:tomato::tomato::tomato::tomato:!

2 Likes