Holiday Baking 2025

I made some more Fruitcake last night. This recipe is mostly a King Arthur Everyone’s Favourite Fruitcake Recipe. I added fancy molasses instead of corn syrup

This morning I made Bits and Bites One loaded pan that was made with Shreddies, Cheerios, ranch cheddar pretzels, cheese nips, pistachios, hazelnuts and almonds, and one nut-free pan that will have a few more additions later.

And my first attempt at Swedish Thumbprint cookies aka Hallongrottor. There are so many variations to this recipe. With egg / without egg, sugar to flour ratio varies a lot as does the flour to baking powder ratio.

A few method issues a few of you can spot LOL.

10 Likes

Keep using those cheap California pistachios: I have a good friend who works as an engineer in a plant that processes pistachios. Gotta keep Eddie employed!

3 Likes

Is very velvety and tastes rich and light at the same time, like a mousse.

4 Likes

First selection of 2025, second selection on the way! These are majority new-to-me recipes this year, and I’m proud of that fact simply because I can be a little bit too set in my ways :slight_smile:

Clockwise:

  1. Luisa Weiss’ lebkuchen from Classic German Baking, enrobed in 70%. I made the dough in October and let it cure til it was time to bake this weekend.
  2. Bon Appetit ginger spice cookies
  3. Lavender sandwich cookies with lemon curd
  4. Dorie Greenspan’s devil’s thumbprints with Callebaut ruby chocolate center
  5. Nicola Lamb’s pistachio and lemon amaretti from Sift, and reprinted here
  6. In the middle: fig and orange sables from Sarah Keiffer

About the amaretti:

This was my first time making amaretti of any kind. The entire recipe was made in the food processor and came together very quickly; it also makes a modest number of cookies, which honestly feels like a bit of a relief at this point.

The recipe called for coriander seeds, and I couldn’t find any, even in the extensive bulk spice section at the natural foods store. I had roasted ground coriander at home, but frankly it had no scent whatsoever, so I didn’t want to use it. I like cardamom and reasoned it would go, so I wound up opening 6-8 green cardamom pods, taking out the black seeds, and pulverizing them in a mortar+pestle, then adding to the nut mixture in the food processor.

I found they baked faster than the instructions specified, so I knocked at least 3 min off the baking time, because burning a cookie this good is a sin. There isn’t much lemon flavor per se, but the cookie is an extremely concentrated little flavor bomb (all nuts, no flour) so I don’t think I missed it. Not with the beautiful pistachio and cardamom flavors going on. I won’t leave it out next time - and there will be a next time - because I’m sure it brightens things in the background. Just know that this isn’t a lemony cookie at all.

The lavender cookies - everybody liked them. I was afraid of overdoing the lavender flavor, partially because my lavender flower was very fragrant. To compensate, I used just shy of the specified amount in this first half-batch. I think I’ll go to the full amount in the next pass.

Also, I rolled out the freshly-made dough before refrigerating, rather than fridging it in a disc and then rolling out, but the whole way I was worried about how dry and crumbly the dough was. Like I said, this was half a batch, so it’s possible the half-amount of liquid in the dough just wasn’t enough. Next time I make it, I will trust my instincts if the dough seems too dry before I get in the fridge.

11 Likes

I cant imagine what the costs here are in T.O and are

1 Like

The lavender/lemon cookies also apparently don’t have much holding power; like, you can’t fill them and then let them sit for a couple days. That’s a negative in my book, at least for gifting purposes. I’m happy to have some un-assembled at home, just putting them together whenever Mom or I want one, but it reduces their utility for cookie boxes.

2 Likes

I paid $25 for 2 very small Caribbean black cakes at the One of a Kind festival 2 weeks ago here in Toronto. These ones didn’t have any nuts. I don’t think they weighed more than 250 grams.

This was the going price of a stollen at Dough Bakeshop on the Danforth yesterday. $25. I think it weighs around a pound. I paid a bit more for a stollen at Noctua in the Junction 2 years ago.


I think most better fruitcakes, stollen and panettone baked in a small business bakery in Toronto usually sell for $40-$50.

2 Likes

So impressive!

2 Likes

Each one looks great to me. When you put these a few at a time on cookie plates, the method “issues” will be invisible.

1 Like

Very tasty Fruitcake cookies, using for the first time a recipe I saved back in 2017 which the “Stephie Cooks” blogger slightly updated this year. I used my 110 cookie scoop (1 tsp), heaping, and got more than 100 cookies. I see from the new blog photos that her’s are quite a bit larger. I used orange juice, not apple. I also made up my own raisins & fruit mix using what I had on hand: 3/4 C golden raisins, 1/2 C raisins, 3 oz (about 10) dried apricots snipped small, 1/4 C. dried cranberries (about 1 oz), 4 oz. pitted dried dates, snipped small, 8 oz. candied cubed pineapple.
I’m baking again today, despite saying I’d wait until next weekend to make the “just for us” recipes. Call it procrasti-baking The other to-do item on my list is cleaning the living room before setting up and decorating our small artificial Christmas tree. Love getting out the ornaments, just not eager to dust & vacuum.

9 Likes

I made cranberry-orange-pecan bread from Sally’s Baking Addiction. I omitted to the streusel and will probably skip the glaze, as the batter seemed plenty sweet. Teacher gifts and a 6" round for us!

15 Likes

those look good !

1 Like

thanks :slight_smile:

The cake was really good, but I let my kid do the whisking and folding in of the dry ingredients. There must have been lumpy baking soda that didn’t dissolve – I got two horrible, bitter bites in the otherwise delicious, moist cake. Now I’m debating whether to gift the little ones after all :confused:

2 Likes

Little ones: cakes? or kids? :sweat_smile:

2 Likes

Look how nicely @rstuart packages her Holiday Treats. :heart:


I’m a lucky girl.

9 Likes

Tonight’s project: candying orange peel :christmas_tree:

4 Likes

My SIL used to make a fruitcake cookie, or actually thousands of them which she gifted to all of us. Tasty, but ugly as sin.

2 Likes

I’m candying orange peel right now in order to make fruitcake cookies!

2 Likes

My neighborhood bakery has Christmas cookies for US$2.50 apiece: Thumbprints and Mexican wedding cookies a little larger than most homemade, 2.5-inch chocolate crinkles and molasses cookies. Decorated sugar cookies are close to $5.

The local food hall’s bakery has not-large fruitcake loaves for $32 and stollen for $27.

1 Like