I got a teak cutting board yesterday. I am using bamboo at the moment.
Any opinion on the pros and cons of each? Or does it really matter? Are there other wooden material I should consider?
Thanks!
I have bamboo, maple, and a mix (antique board). I seldom use the bamboo anymore as I feel that the others are easier on my knives. May not make a difference but it just seems that way and feels better.
1 Like
I agree with you. Bamboo seems pretty hard on the knives.
Additional question for everyone: Oil or no oil? I didnât oil my bamboo board and performed no maintenance. Its getting a little moldy. Its said oiling prevent absorption of moisture. I was thinking about danish oil that I already have but want to hear if its really effective. Thoughts?
Hi sck,
both bamboo and teak contain silicates which make them less acceptable as cutting boardsânot as bad as glass or ceramics, but in the wrong direction for sure. Soft woods and plastics are hard to keep clean. End grain hard woods like maple take the prizeâbut overkill for me. Iâve got three different sizes: the smaller two are hardwoodâthe big one is poly plastic with the consistency and appearance of wax. I often use them together.
All unfinished woods need to be oiled to prevent them from drying out, cracking, and just not looking very good. Bamboo isnât wood, and itâs treated. IMO, it does not need to be oiled.
2 Likes
I have heard that both teak and bamboo can be too hard for knives. However, you should give them a try and see. They may not be that bad especially for most home cooks. I also heard people suggest pine wood and hinoki wood are too soft, and that the perfect cutting board should only be made out of maple, cherry and walnut and nothing else. I think that is a little too absolute.
I would use them and let your experience speak for their abilities. They are not glass and marble stone.
Thanks drrayeye.
What kind of treatment does bamboo get? Are you referring to Boric + Borax or something else?
I look into wood hardness more and it seems like the answer is a bit more complicated:
Different types of bamboo definitely is, on average, harder than wood like maple. Teak is not as hard as bamboo. But it depends on what type of teak it is. Mine says plantation teak, so I assume its the type of teak that they grow with much fertilizer and is less dense than old growth teak. This assumption comes from an observation that I made previously working with plantation grown redwood and pinewood. They are a little bit like foam, much less dense compared to old growth ones.
Since its only $10 (Madeira brand), and I donât have truly expensive knives, I am inclined to give the teak a try.
Hi sck,
Bamboo is impregnated with a resin, or it will rot. I treat it like it has been varnishedâkeep it clean and dry.
Ray
Good analysis, sck,
I love teak, and have many pieces of teak furniture in my home, including a newer âplantationâ tray. I see your point.
I almost feel that teak is too beautiful to be used as a cutting board, and the silicate issue still remains, but, like Chem, I wouldnât rule it out.
Ray
I love my Boos (maple) board, but certainly there are other woods that are fine for cutting boards. However, IMO bamboo isnât one of them. My husband bought me a bamboo board as a gift once and I returned it after one use. I absolutely hated the feel of the cutting surface. YMMV, but I would definitely look at maple boards before anything else.
I use maple cutting boards and clean them with mild soap and vinegar. A couple of times each year and wipe them down with generic mineral oil.
I also never oil my bamboo. I only use it for when I smoke meat because of itâs size. As for the maple end grain board I use Howard cutting board oil. Seems to work well.
