Brooklyn Copper Ordering Window

Yes😢, cryingly expensive. But arguably among the best cookware ever made.

1 Like

It is, by all accounts, as fine as anything being made today. Their style and details are impeccable. After 3/4 of a lifetime building out my own kitchen, these would look fancy enough to be out of place, and so I shall pass. I am grateful these were not available when I began.

I love copper but the tin scares me…I’m afraid that somehow I will screw it up and melt the tin.
A few years ago I invested in some Falk pieces, and I have been extremely happy with them as my daily drivers.

Why Brooklyn copper is better?

Oh yeah. I remember you prefer the stainless steel surface.

It is heavy and meticulously constructed, but so were many of the pans of old. The filet of sole can’t tell the difference. Heck, it probably couldn’t recognize Tramontina. On the other hand, Tramontina wouldn’t give you goosebumps without even having food in it.

1 Like

Glad you love your Falk. I have a tinned sauté pan that has been in use about half a century without needing to be re-tinned. If you use wooden or silicone tools it is pretty easy to maintain. Tin and stainless cook quite differently, but the difference is easily masked with butter, oil, or some other fat.

Sure, this is a common fear. Common, that is, among people who don’t already own and use tinned copper. Unless you leave a pan empty over heat, it’s not very realistic.

In all the years I’ve constantly been using it (and maybe 60 pieces), I’ve had precisely ONE minor incident with bubbled/smeared tin. This was a vintage frypan that had been obviously and somewhat sloppily re-tinned. I suspect the newer tin was just applied over the remnants of the old. Even then, the pan didn’t require retinning.

Now, there are reasons not to prefer tin linings. If you (or others in your kitchen) can’t NOT: (a) scour; (b) cook using metal utensils; or (c) cut and serve foods in and from the pan with knives and metal tools, then maybe choose something else.

Falk is very good stuff. The issue for me with bimetal is that the max thickness is 2.3mm of copper. Reasonable minds can differ over whether thicker is preferable, but if you want thicker, tinned (or silvered) is the only choice. Thicker is my preference, and vintage tinned extra fort pans in good condition can often be had for far less money.

I view BCC as a choice for those who want–and can afford-- the best features of premier vintage pans in totally new condition. Over a lifetime of cooking, it’s not that expensive.

1 Like

Well said Kaleo, and I do respect your judgement and comments. i think if we were to all look at our net investment in knives and cookware in here, we would be quite shocked. I think over the years my greatest financial investment in kitchen/cooking items would be my kitchen knives, and that I am not willing to confess in detail in this public venue or I would be pilloried. Let’s just say I like sharp things.

1 Like

But did we not already say expensive cookware do not yield better cooking skill?
Wabi. Don’t want to derail the conversation… which is your most used/or most beloved kitchen knife?
To make you feel better, I also buy computer better than my gaming skill.

Chem, my most used knife in my kitchen is a Teruyasu Fujiwara Denka 180mm gyuto,. followed by a similar nakiri and a Takeda petty. Those are my standard dinner prep knives.

1 Like

Those Denkas are really sweet blades💪