2026 Winter (February-March) COTM / Cookbook of the Month + COOKING FROM thread – DIANA HENRY

RUSSIAN CHICKEN & MUSHROOM PIE

I planned to make a chicken pie of some sort to use up chicken breast I had poached, so I thought I’d take a look at the current COTMs as well as the Ina Garten COTM to see if a recipe jumped out at me.

I was about to start down the Barefoot Contessa path when I this one caught my eye with a flavor combination I love — Eastern European / Russian mushroom-forward and sour cream-laced.

This is a very simple recipe: mushrooms, onions, and chicken in a sour cream-enhanced white sauce. I started by dry-sauteeing the mushrooms, then removed them and sauteed the onions and garlic, added the flour and then the milk for the sauce, and then added back the mushrooms with the chicken. I used a mix of cremini and shiitake mushrooms. The recipe calls for dill, which I don’t like, so I added scallions and green peas for freshness, plus a pinch of thyme with the mushrooms.

I borrowed a tip from the BC pot pie recipe and added some chicken bouillon and mushroom bouillon to deepen the flavor of the sauce, along with some double concentrated homemade chicken broth.

The filling is absolutely delicious, like a lighter stroganoff. I divided it into two, and used a press-in crust to top one, but ate the other with crumbled pita chips in lieu of crust (which was perfect, actually).

I can see making this again as a saucy chicken dish served with some crusty bread or kasha, or topped with mashed potato likes shepherd’s pie.

Really good and really simple, will be repeated.

9 Likes