Return to Oz (1985) - dir Walter Murch
Walter Murch is a curious figure. Widely celebrated for his editing and sound design, especially in the peak years of folks like Coppola and Lucas, he’s a rightly respected creative figure, spoken of in concert with those ‘new Hollywood’ types, the Bagdonovitches and the Altmans. But he only ever directed a single feature film, and a deeply strange one it is.
Return To Oz is attempting to serve multiple masters. On the one hand, Disney licensed to Oz sequels The Land of Oz and Ozma of Oz, and the story is a (very) rough conglomeration of the two. On the other hand, Disney knew than the majority of the intended audience was unlikely to have read ANY of the Oz books, never mind two different sequels. Almost everyone watching this movie will familiar with it ONLY through the 1939 film by MGM. That means Return to Oz is trying to be a sequel two VERY different versions of the story.
Like the book, Dorothy is much younger, played by a 12 year old Faruzia Balk (Nancy from The Craft). And like the book, the version feels much MUCH darker than the classic film. But Disney ALSO paid a huge sum to MGM to use ‘ruby slippers’ instead of the ‘silver shoes’ of the book, and often deferred to movie versions of plot beats rather than book equivalents.
When I say the film is dark, it plays like a legitimate horror movie aimed at tweens and early teens while simultaneously being a lazy retread of the first movie. We have 12 year old girl about to be subjected to shock treatment (instead of a tornado) and the doctor and nurse turned into the Oz-dwelling evil Queen Mombi (who steals heads!) and the Gnome king (rather than the salesman and Mrs
Gulch appearing as the Wizard and Wicked Witch) we have a DIFFERENT scarecrow (Jack Pumpkinhead), mechanical man (Tick Tock, a soldier instead of a woodsman) and strange creature allied a Gump (an enchanted moose) taking the place of the Lion. There’s also Dorothy’s companion from the real world, a chicken named Belinda, taking Toto’s place.
The effects in this movie are of a quality that totally outclasses the film itself. Eerie, stop motion rock creatures, along with the Gnome King, are genuinely unnerving. Belinda the chicken is played by a truly remarkable animatronic bird being carefully cut in with a real chicken, and the results are astonishingly convincing.
This whole thing is a fascinating misfire from a Disney that was still finding its way out of the doldrums in the mid 80’s. If you have a middle-schooler in your life that seems interested in the offbeat and weird, show them this. You’ll instantly be one of the cooler adults in their eyes.