A new jewish deli called the Pickled Herring opened last week on Route 9 in Marlboro in the shopping center with Kohls. This is the location that used to be Jerry & Harveys. They have opened with a limited menu which will be expanded when they can open the dining room and of course are currently takeout or curbside pickup only. The stuff in the cases looks good and the owners are experienced deli owners. One of them is Jesse from the former Jesse and Davids in Marlboro.
We got matzo ball soup which was just ok. We also split a pastrami sandwich and a brisket sandwich both of which were very good. Also some very good potato salad and pickles.
The lox, whitefish, herring etc looked nice and will be the next thing we try. Interestingly they have 2 varieties of most meats like corned beef, pastrami etc. A kosher version and a non kosher version. I had the non kosher which they said is made for them by a Brooklyn supplier. They also have separate kosher slicers.