When I was reading this thread last year, I wasn’t thinking of buying any pan. But then I noticed my old pan (actually it was husband’s pan, he bought it some 18 years ago), the bottom disc welded was starting to detach, heat wasn’t even on my induction cook top. My choice was quick, after a search on Demeyere pans (which are out of budget) and with the Mauviel’s M’Cook promotion in January, I got myself a 5 ply 11" (28cm) pan. I must say I am happy and impressed with my purchase. I need a pan to go inside the oven, a 11" is ideal for me, although a bigger size that SCK is testing would be great.
Unlike most other pans and pots I had, they have a lot of information under the pan, sometimes etched, sometimes debossed, meaning less contact with the induction surface, I am happy that the bottom of this M’Cook pan has absolutely nothing, not even printed. The tiny debossed “made in France” was seen on the side.
I have successfully cooked thick steaks without adding oil (to test the pan), and it didn’t stick to the pan, browned nicely and evenly. I tried once to cook an omelette, didn’t stick to the pan either. I had some problems cooking diced potatoes though, they got stuck with quite badly, but I suspected it was due the fact that the pan was not hot enough. I confirmed the heat-conducting core ran up the sides of the pan, I got myself burnt more than I thought by slightly touching it (it wasn’t part of the pan test, but with my old pan, no problem if touching the side).
No lid with this purchase, need to buy that separately, but since I have a heavy glass lid from one of my cast iron pot the same size, it is good enough for me. If I have something to criticise, the pan after usage would have some “stain” like pattern on the metal inside the pan, especially when I made those “water beans” to see if pan was hot enough, I guess you need to use special polish to make it look good again. The handle of this pan might not be the most comfortable and probably need some time to adjust, but since I own a non stick pan from Mauviel’s cheaper line, I get used to it and I find it actually quite aesthetically pleasing.