Recommendations for seafood markets near North New Jersey or NYC or mail order

Regional Dining Discussions New Jersey
1

I just get most of my seafood from Costco now - Ahi Tuna, Swordfish, scallops etc…

But does anyone know of anywhere in North New Jersey or the NYC area (with competitive prices that don’t charge a premium) or by mailing (competitive pricing)?

There are a lot of mail order seafood places online but they all have premium pricing or requires an order of $400 or more.

I’m sure NYC has a lot of great seafood markets but the cost is usually twice that of normal.

Costco prices are: $16 a lb ahi tuna; $16 a lb swordfish; $24 lb halbiut etc.

Numbers higher than that but still close would be great if possible

thank you

3 Likes
2

I live right near them but others on here - I think @paryzer is one - have raved about Local 130 Seafood. THEY DELIVER all over NJ.

5 Likes
3

I second Local 130 Seafood. They deliver fresh caught fish all over NJ in a day or so, and a couple of days to other states. Their prices are higher than Costco, but Costco might be frozen and not caught fresh that day.

3 Likes
4

Third to Local130. Reminds me, time to place an order!

2 Likes
5

Fourth!

1 Like
6

Fifth, I ordered from them when the shit hit the fan and my delivery was on my porch the next morning

1 Like