They usually have a lamb vindaloo in the buffet (I ate it last night) that is beyond words. The sauce rich, spicy, and flavorful. The lamb falls apart in your mouth as if it had been stewing for hours.
When I order off the menu, I get the chicken makhni or chicken tikka masala. Kind of boring, I know, but they are just too amazing to pass up. Their food is not usually spicy, but I ask them to crank it up. They usually listen. 
Onion kulcha is a good substitute for naan. The Neelam special appetizer is a good way to start your meal if you have never been there because they include a little bit of everything. Their tandoori shrimp is also delightful. Really plump, tender shrimp. All meals come with basmati rice and they sometimes throw in a small tray of vegetable korma on the house as well.
