Milk Sugar Love Creamery and Bakeshop

@Roro1831’s post on the Food News topic reminded me that I wanted to start one for Milk Sugar Love, so here you go!

This is an opening that I’ve certainly been excited about…I first met the owner when she did a popup at C’est Cheese here in AP. She made ice cream sandwiches with (iirc) brie ice cream w a ripple of fig jam, and they were served on prosciutto cookies. (Read that again if you need to.) YES, PLEASE! She’s also been at the AP farmer’s market with her cart, and for the last few weeks leading up to the official shop opening last weekend, the cart has been in front of the shop. That’s where I tried both the Bodega, Bodega and Sour Cream Blueberry flavors.

Bodega, Bodega is described as a Frito base (yes, FRITOS) with zebra cakes and cosmic brownie pieces in it. I honestly wasn’t sure what I’d think but WOW. If you like salty and sweet, it’s a MUST-try if it’s in the case. The Sour Cream Blueberry description: rich, sour cream-based ice cream swirled with a blueberry jam made with cinnamon, ginger, and other spices. DELICIOUS!! And I’ll get over there this weekend to try the blueberry that @Roro1831 mentioned because I can’t get enough bloobs right now.

I didn’t know a thing about this place before the word got out, but Emma (the owner) has competed on Chopped and the JC location has been on many lists for ‘best of’ for the last 5+ years, so the street cred is there.

Click here for the Milk Sugar Love website

If you’re headed to AP and want to meet up, let me know!

5 Likes

Dropped in last week and tried the Bodega Bodega (me) and the Lemon Olive Oil with crushed pieces of cone (her). As noted by @CurlzNJ, the Bodega Bodega tastes just like Fritos. If you’re a corn chip person, as I am, fantastic. The Lemon Olive Oil was next level delicious and I had more than a few spoonfuls. The blueberry flavors had sold out by the time of my visit, but I’ll be back!

2 Likes

We drove by last night after dinner at Xina, as much as I wanted a scoop my better senses told me to keep driving lol

1 Like

Went to a dinner party last night and dessert was make your own ice cream sandwiches. The ice cream was from milk sugar love.

Three flavors, salted caramel which I have had before, chocolate, and one of their new seasonal flavors, summer corn and blueberries.

I had seen the new flavors posted online, so went in immediately for the summer corn and blueberries…needless to say I may be going there today to buy a pint.

1 Like

For the record, I named Raspberry Park!!! She posted the IG that she hadn’t yet named thet flavor and was taking suggestions. :grin:

5 Likes

Do you get a free scoop for that? Lol

Sure hope so!