Lake Inez's Mystery Patio [Toronto] - fun food, drinks, and host


Other posters and I have previously reported on Lake Inez’s Mystery Patio previously, I am happy to note that this year’s edition is just as worth it.


As noted above, there is one seating per evening at 7:00 PM. You are served 6 courses with drink pairings (you can also order other drinks) and some dietary preferences can be accommodated with advance notice. The patio has covering for the tables, but if it is raining hard and the wind is blowing, some of you could still get wet. For chillier evenings, there are heaters also. Dinner goes to about 10:00.


The cooking remains excellent, emphasizing what is seasonal, with creative mixing of flavours. Each course has a fanciful name, sometimes with a painful pun. The plating is done on the patio and then the chefs introduce each dish.


The wine list emphasizes smaller producers from less-celebrated wine countries and includes hilarious, if opaque, descriptions. And owner Zac Schwartz continues to be an engaging host, introducing each drink with a rambling and often very tangential story.

The first course was “Makin’ zucchini pancakes”:


This featured a lovely dip of mayo from confit tomatoes, garlic scape and tomato agrodolce underneath, dark green lovage oil, and zucchini blossoms.

This gets scooped onto fried zucchini bread (crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside) with Gunn’s hill cheese and more bits of zucchini flowers. This was accompanied by a pink/salmon cocktail in a coupe glass: tanqueray gin, absinthe, ginger beer, rose petal lemonade - fragrant and floral.

The second course was “Salty sweet fields forever”:


Fresh hamachi sashimi, with strawberry sauce done in the style of ume boshi (Japanese pickled plum), argan oil, dehydrated strawberry slices, red shiso leaf - strawberries were not the flavour I ever would have thought to pair with fish and shiso, but it worked really well. This was paired with an apricot-y pet nat aligoté from Burgundy with indigenous yeast.

The third course was “Moralless yet morelful”:


Fresh morels stuffed with chicken farcis, roasted beets, salted cherry leaves, agrodolce whole cherries, Spanish smoked paprika, green sorrel - lots of complex flavours, with umami, sweet, sour, salty, and smokey all together. This was paired with an orange wine: Kolombour (colombard and bourboulenc grapes), made in Jura, Karnage winery, unfiltered, stone fruity and floral.

The fourth course was “The humm of the bass”:


Lightly deep-fried and flakey white striped bass with a creamy fava bean hummus, Meyer lemon marmalade, and sudachi. This was paired with a Slovakian 2020 Rizling - stonefruity and barnyardy, lime zest.

The fifth course was “The road to summertime is paved with cheeky flowers”:


Luscious beef cheek (smoked 7 hours) with an aji chili rub, lemony baby potatoes, aji verde, with nasturtium leaves and flowers. This was paired with Vendredi 13 Vino di Anna, Mt Etna (nerello mascalese) - light, sour cherries.

And for dessert, “Suburbs; poolside”


Semifreddo with a nod to root beer floats, with molasses-like syrup of sarsaparilla, ginger, chaga mushrooms, with fresh chervil, fennel, anise hyssop on top and soft crust underneath. This was paired with a cocktail of cocoa nib tea, roasted black sesame syrup, bourbon, sweet vermouth, amaro nonino, lemon juice, tahini coconut foam and Meyer lemon powder on top - really interesting sesame and bitter flavours.

Alas, they are no longer serving the Coney dog as a snack later on with more drinks. The owner explained that it was just too much for the kitchen to deal with on-top of everything else. No matter. Still a great experience overall.

6 Likes

I have a res for later this month.
We were there in May and every dish was different from what you had.
I can’t think of a better dining ‘experience’ in Toronto - possibly better food elsewhere but the ‘Mystery Patio’ is magic.

1 Like

It is a great experience - a wonderful combination of factors that makes for a great evening.

We introduced some friends to the Mystery Patio recently. The food remains wonderful - seasonal, interesting, and playful. The wine and drink pairings are enjoyable and feature smaller producers. And Zac continues to be an entertaining and somewhat unfiltered host.

To refresh you, they first provide sopping wet cold towels scented with cucumber, tomato leaf, melon skin, and pink pepper. Then it was on to the tasting menu:


“Prelude: the pain is mightiest with the sword” - sourdough focaccia, fresh tomatoes from White Lily Farms, cured swordfish, lovage, oregano, and a sauce of smoked cherry tomatoes and charred serranos - meaty fish and wonderfully fresh tomatoes, nicely accented by the herbs.

The next course was paired with a cocktail of Aviation gin, lime juice, star anise syrup, honeydew melon juice, and a maraschino cherry - playful and refreshing.

“Cucumber?! I barely know her!” - heirloom cucumber slices, pickled cucumber, striped jack, ginger, mint, basil, with a clarified broth - light, fresh, with nice textural contrasts.

Our next pairing was a 2022 Chardonnay Pet-Nat from Keenan Wines, Cawston, BC, described as being made like champagne but also under flor (this didn’t make much sense, but we couldn’t clarify further) - delightfully apricot-y. It went with “That’ll do diver, that’ll do, pig” - cold green ramen from Oji Seichi in tarragon sesame cream, with peas, truffle, sudachi juice, and allium over raw diver sea scallop - supple, chewy noodles in a fragrant sauce, with sweet scallops.

Our third pairing was Fleurs Macération, Brand et Fils, Ergersheim, Alsace 2022 - Pinot Gris, 5 months on skins and stems - citrus and mineral, with a bit of tannin. It accompanied “Tokyode on a Grecian urn”- Japanese turnip, pollock roe with chili paste, shiso lemon sauce, decorated with nori, geranium petals, and pickled scapes - one of our friend’s favourite dishes.

The next wine was a 2022 Ashanta Rosé de Tempranillo, Covelo, California - a little mushroom and a bit of green strawberry. It paired well with “Orange land, pink lake, this dish” (described better by the Venn diagram) - rainbow trout from Affinity Fish, BBQ-sauced baby carrots with sherry miso-marigold leaf oil sauce - great combo of slightly rich fish with tangy-sweet carrots.

We next had a chilled Iruai Giallo Nebbiolo 2021, from California, élevage almost two years. It had lots of cherries, which matched well with “Lettuce be fowl? Just this once?” - one-week aged duck breast, koji rice, confit duck leg, potato croquette with fermented escarole, shallot and turnip tops, jasmine flower, compressed honeydew melon, thin slices, pickled escarole with yuzu - deeply flavourful meat, with mellowed bitter greens.

For the dessert pairing, we had Magiantosa “Aranciu”, Amaro All’Arancia, Sicily - a delicious mix of blood orange peel, anise, fennel seeds, and clove. It complemented “Me + You; Poolside” - an apricot ice cream sandwich, with anise hyssop in the macaroon, fresh and candied apricot skin dust - cool, creamy, with a hint of licorice.

Zac informed us that they will soon be opening a bar a few doors down, offering cocktails and some choice nibbles (perhaps a return of the Detroit coney dog?).

3 Likes

Food looks fantastic and thank you for sharing! Will be going for the 1st time next month and can’t wait

1 Like

We were there last night, with a similar menu. The only difference was that your ‘Tokyode On A Grecian urn’ was replaced by a Zucchini dish (of various sizes and colours) with hertage tomato skins.

As always, a special evening - and, to emphasize, the architect of the food, is Jay Moore - this is the fourth restaurant I’ve followed him to. IMO one of the most talented chefs in Toronto - and the reason I even ventured to Lake Inez when he originally joined them.

1 Like

Was he at Shoto at the same time as Mitch Bates? That might explain the connection with the Oji Seichi noodles being used on the menu, although I guess chefs can form connections other ways.

Yes, they were there at the same time.
Mitch went off to (eventually) Grey Gardens and then Oji Seichi (although I’ve never actually seen him cooking at O.S.).
Jay went off to Momofuku Ko in New York (the penultimate location) and then (subsequently) returned to Toronto at M&M BBQ (in Kensington) - I think that location is now a Vegan place. Then he went to Lake Inez, originally under Robbie Hojilla, although I think Robbie had health problems and Jay gradually exerted more influence.

And, expanding the connections, we visited our Granddaughter at University in Iowa City and went to the ‘top’ restaurant there. The chef recognised us (which impressed the Granddaughter!) - it was (and is) Sam Gelman who was Executive chef at Shoto at the same time Jay and Mitch were there. It’s a small culinary world.

1 Like

Great posts… Is it communal dining?

No. Separate Tables. But each course seved simultaneously to every table.

Just went to Mystery Patio and loved it! Fun experience and food was very good. Also appreciate how they try to source locally. I do think serving over 30 people at the same time is a challenge. It wasn’t a problem for the cold or room temp dishes but when we got to the meat, the duck was well grilled and tasty but would have been much better if warmer

1 Like