Kaya -- Jamaican in SF mid-market

Kaya, helmed by Kingston 11 chef Nigel Jones, opened in 2018 and is a partnership with Daniel Patterson, who previously occupied Alta at the same location (RIP smoked bialys). On a weekend at 11am, with no competition from the weekday tech crowd, the “Jamaican Food & Rum Bar” was an easy walk-in. I’m interested to hear other’s thoughts on dinner and drinks.

Jamaican patty, with beef, had a meaty oniony backdrop and a bold set of seasonings, not overly assertive on the spice heat but the flavors had good staying power. The smooth filling was embedded in a flaky, yellow-hued crust, presumably butter-based. I’d like to do a side-by-side with the ones at Peaches Patties Jamaican Kitchen in Bernal, an affiliate of La Cocina (i.e., SFBA’s culinary Marvel Universe), which I recall being equally good, but with an even heavier spicing.

Salt fish fritters were more nuanced than homogenous-centered Spanish/Portuguese versions I’ve had. Kaya’s had identifiable fish and potato chunks, cemented together into a solid mass, and breaded in a way that I experienced waves of crunch. The chimichurri brightened an already vibrantly flavored dish.

Jerk chicken salad had a good mix of flavors and textures-- mango, plantains, and mixed greens. The chicken, fragrant mostly from cloves, had some dry bits that didn’t matter too much embedded in a forkful of other stuff.

Opentable is showing plenty of open spaces for brunch reservations, even for large groups, in upcoming weeks. It’s ridiculous that a place so good, of an underrepresented style of food, and close to BART is empty as people across the city queue up for pancakes and benedicts they could cook themselves if they weren’t hungover. On that note, the Cinnamon French Toast looked pretty good and the Asian Art Museum, Civic Center Playground, Sunday Civic Center farmer’s market, and Bi-Rite Kiosk are nearby.


I’m going to have to check it out, but not used to thinking about traveling ( through East Bay) to SF for Caribbean. OTOH, we DO travel to Florida for Caribbean!

1 Like

What’s good in the east bay? And have you had a chance to try the chef’s east bay restaurant, Kingston 11, and if so what did you think?

(Isla Vida is another Caribbean option if you have SF plans near Fillmore/Japantown)

1 Like

Can’t say I have much recent personal experience, although I have some “bookmarks.”, and we’ve tried some in years past. . That’s why I immediately ETA we end up saving our Caribbean exploits for back east.


Will probably get to Kingston 11 first, if the patties are as good as THOSE look. Texting Kingston 11 to husband right now!

When we return from back east we have a separate suit case for the patties. But not feeling potatoes in salt fish cakes. My in laws seem to think potatoes are… foreign.

1 Like

Kingston is excellent. Those salt cod fritters look more spherical than the ones at Kingston, but your report of the chunky texture sounds similar to what we had.

We tried the goat curry - good curry, not much goat. Winner was the oxtails with the white beans, which was terrific.

Best of all was the rum cake with rum raisin ice cream. OMG, a match made in boozy heaven!

Sadly, this was back in 2016 so no idea if the food has held up under Nigel Jones splitting his time. My DH doesn’t care for Caribbean food as much I do, so we haven’t returned :frowning: ,


Closed. In SF, Isla Vida and Peaches Patties are remaining options for Jamaican & Afro-Caribbean food.

1 Like

Wow. Patterson opens and closes restaurants more often than I change my pants.
Too bad for the SF Caribbean food scene. I wasn’t too impressed with Peaches Patties but haven’t yet tried Isla Vida. Miss Ollie’s in Oakland remains one of my favorite restaurants, Caribbean or otherwise.


I just found out that Isla Vida is from the Farmer Brown guy, in the context of learning Farmer Brown closed!!!

SF Soul Food Institution Closes After More Than a Decade

Isla Vida was tremendous (ribs, chicken) in early July. Went back today and it was very closed, looked permanent. They had $ troubles. Does anyone know more?

1 Like

Late coming to this discussion, but Kingston 11 is quite good, if pricey. A nice option if you’re going to the Paramount.

Interesting! I see an article about financial troubles, but the website still seems to be up.

Yelp says reported closed. Caviar no longer recognizes restaurant. Online ordering disabled.

A real shame. This was one of the few new openings this year to celebrate. A gem.

Thanks to SF supes for making it so hard to function in the city.

1 Like

So sad. I just posted about this a minute ago but see you beat me too it.
I went on Friday night to get another Cubano which I loved (and could eat as is thanks to Manchego not being cow cheese).