ISO Boston-area retail oysters

Hi Gang: where do you get your oysters? My dad visited last weekend and shared his recipe for (lightly) grilled oysters on the half-shell (along the lines of Rockefeller). I ponied up for the $1.75 Sandy Necks at the Legal Seafood market in Chestnut Hill and we polished 2 dozen off with a nice Sancerre. Are there cheaper retail places to get reliably fresh, unshucked oysters?

I’ve bought fresh unshucked oysters at the Burlington Wegmans; they had PEI and Blue Points when I was there last, but I don’t recall the price. Bonus (?): half of them had pea crabs.

Tough to beat that price and not sacrifice quality.

Other places I have generally gotten fresh oysters include Jordan Brothers (many local farmers markets, Alive & Kicking, New Deal and a 2nd for Wegmans. You can order bulk bags online from places such as Island Creek or Mac’s and get the price down to $1.50 or below if you are ordering 50+ oysters.

Sometimes Whole Foods will have a special for $1.50 or less. However I have found WF seafood to be very inconsistent and oysters aren’t something I really want to buy on special. However if you are grilling them I suppose you have a bit more leeway.

Thanks, I’ll certainly check out Wegman’s. And I agree about Whole Foods. There are some seafoods that they turn over frequently enough for me to trust them, but not oysters.

On the Mass Pike today I passed a truck for Copps Island Oysters, from Norwalk CT. Like Island Creek they will deliver; their prices are substantially lower. I think I’ll check them out, too.

I can’t remember the pricing, but we have had good luck with the oysters we got at Fresh Pond Seafood in Arlington.

Help cover Hungry Onion's costs when you shop at Amazon!

Honghe Hani Rice Terraces, Yuanyang County, Yunnan
Credit: inkelv1122, Flickr