Interesting reddit thread asking non-Americans "what's the best American food?"

While I’ll readily admit I haven’t read all 34,600 comments, many of them surprised me.

Deep fried turkey. Curly fries. Everything about Thanksgiving dinner. Mac-n-cheese. Chocolate chip cookies. Raw cookie dough that’s safe to eat. Waffle House (everything on the menu, from a German guy, and a Spaniard who agrees but added TexMex food, Reuben sandwiches, and fried chicken with waffles). Cornbread. Anything Cajun, but especially gumbo. Soul food. New York Style pizzas.

My favorite reply so far is:

  • I saw this post and have been waiting for my non-American husband to come home. I asked him this question and fully expected him to say brisket or BBQ ribs. He straight up said Cinnamon Toast Crunch. I’m embarrassed.
10 Likes

I havent contributed to Reddit, but am happy to give an answer here (bearing in mind we have only visited Eastern states).

In the South, it’ll be BBQ.

In New England, it’ll be seafood. Even though I live on this small island off the coast of Europe, surrounded by seas full of nice things to eat, we do not generally appreciate seafood here. New England seafood restaurant offerings far surpasses our own.

10 Likes

As I’m skimming the thread, New England clam chowder and lobster rolls are some of the most frequently mentioned, as is BBQ, especially beef brisket.

2 Likes

My European relatives seem to love and seek out apple pie when they visit North America.

3 Likes

For me, as a Canadian, when I visit the South, it’s fried chicken, crab cakes, hush puppies, peach cobbler, pralines and pecan pie.

In New England, it’s lobster rolls and fried clams.

In California, Mexican food, artichokes, crab louie and cioppino.

In Colorado, chile verde.

4 Likes

Shepherd’s Pie and Peking Duck!

2 Likes

All my favourite American dishes are sandwich based, Reuben sandwich, lobster roll, Philly cheesesteak., French dip sandwich If pushed though and I have this the most, it would be a Wendys’ single cheeseburger.

6 Likes

My European friends generally fall head over heels with buffalo chicken (wings or a sandwich), barbecue, key kime pie, and my chocolate chip cookies.

4 Likes

But that’s not American food (or are you talking about heavily Americanized Mexican food, e.g. Taco Bell etc). For me American food has to be something which isn’t similarly relatively easily available in other countries (e.g. NE seafood, different kind of pies) or has originated in other countries and was later modified in the US (e.g. pizza). I see something like Cajun/Creole food as something uniquely (regional) American food

1 Like

As someone who’s originally a non-American :wink: — bbq, buffalo wings, BLTs, club sammiches, lobster rolls, southern fried chicken.

4 Likes

I’m not sure what it is about buffalo sauce that hits all the buttons, but regardless of country of origin, everyone loves it!

I brought back a few bottles of wing sauce when we lived in Paris and made a batch of wings for a party. One friend came up for air (he’d just inhaled a half-dozen) and excitedly declared that these would be good with beer!l. Lol. Yes, Jean-Paul, they would!

5 Likes

I’d be an exception. I find it too spicy but, also, I’m not fond of wings, in general. In fact, apart from sandwiches, I’m not that fond of anything where I’m using my fingers to eat.

The Mexican food made and sold in California is Californian and American, as far as I’m concerned. I seek out the dishes that are done poorly in Canada.

The food cooked by recent Mexican immigrants opening restaurants in Toronto where I live is nothing like Californian Californian Mexican food.

Taco Bell has its place, but I can find that in Canada. I don’t bother with what I can find at home when I travel.

The Cajuns lived in Acadia (in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick- some Acadian communities still exist in Canada) before arriving in Louisiana, and Creole food has its roots in the Caribbean and Africa.

Not sure I follow or agree with your logic.

Food evolves as people move around.

YMMV.

For our family’s relatives in Scandanavia, it’s always “american” pancakes and burgers. In N Out etc. There’s less beef over there.

1 Like

I also like American pancakes for breakfast, with syrup (although I don’t like the thin crispy bacon that often comes with them in the States). I usually have a pack from the supermarket in the freezer, ready to microwave. And, for breakfast, I never think to have our own pancakes (the sort Americans and the French call crepes).

2 Likes

As someone who grew up in New England, I am disqualified from answering this (although I am deeply appreciative of those who have chimed in regarding Atlantic lobster rolls and fried belly clams…I mean, I didn’t make 'em, but I am appreciative!). I think if I wanted to introduce someone from abroad to “American food”, I’d want to have them try something like a taco from the Kogi truck. I feel like one of the things American food provides, when done well, is the creation of a marriage between cultures (I hesitate to say “fusion” because, as Martin Yan once put it, the is also “confusion” on that path) that leads to something that can be better than the sum of the parts. I think that is also one of the reasons Buffalo wings are a standout - who would’ve though that a fried wing, hot sauce, butter, and blue cheese would work?

8 Likes

There’s an American invention called Boneless Wings (chicken fingers in wing sauce) for people who don’t like wings, or don’t want to get their fingers dirty. I can’t speak for all American wing joints, but in neighbouring Canada, wings at most places usually come in at least mild, medium, hot, suicide, honey garlic, and often salt & pepper.

Also, a lazy cioppino is available in many northern Californian restaurants that serve cioppino, which has the crab taken out of the shell, so there is less effort, less mess, and the hands stay clean, for a small surcharge.

1 Like

Not to mention the infamous Buffalo Wing Dip. :slightly_smiling_face:https://www.franksredhot.com/en-ca/recipes/franks-redhot-buffalo-chicken-dip

1 Like

Is there a definition of American food?
What makes something distinctly us?
When does a dish become ours?
Because, besides Native American cuisine, all our dishes originally came from elsewhere, didn’t they?

2 Likes
Help cover Hungry Onion's costs when you shop at Amazon!

Bessarabsky Market, Kyiv. Ukraine
Credit: Juan Antonio Segal, Flickr