Hearth & Hug [Davis Square, Somerville MA]:

The moral of the story: a bowl of lettuce does not a salad make, even if one is a small rodent.

So, as I posted elsewhere, this cute little bakery opened right around the corner from me, and I so want them to succeed. (At least partly because I have $200 in kickstarter credits left to spend there.) But… after 3 visits, it’s time to write up what I really think. These guys are going to have to get their act together or they won’t make it, despite their excellent location and crowds lined up out the door for their opening.

We stopped in yesterday for lunch, as the pastry and coffee side of the menu had previously been sampled and did not bear immediate repeating. There was confusion about what the sopapillas plate was made with as far as flour, and despite looking it up in a binder and stating “AP” flour, the very nice person working in the kitchen would not be believe me that I was 100% sure AP flour is wheat and wheat only, and no, he really didn’t need to check any further. I went with the salmon sandwich on gluten free bread. My husband ordered the fried chicken thigh sandwich, and after some hemming and hawing about what was actually in the seasonal salad, my sprout ordered a side salad. Well, it took a very long time for any food to be ready, and when I did pick up my sandwich the bread was ice cold. Not like room temp, but well-chilled. The chicken sandwich was luke-warm, with untoasted room temp bread, and the fries were limp and barely warm. But the kicker was that my sprout’s “side salad” was… a bowl of lettuce!

This is so obviously not a “salad” that I had to take a photo. I mean, there is nary a shred of carrot or stray cucumber in there. So, we decamped to home. Very helpful nice staff, wrapped up all the orders happily, and then we walked home to fix their lackluster food.

The sandwiches went in the toaster oven- GF bread especially is completely inedible without a decent amount of toasting, IMO. A fried chicken sandwich and french fries likewise should be hot. Luckily, we have a full kitchen where we can make such things reality. The toasted version of the salmon sandwich was actually excellent, and generous portion. Since my sprout is no amateur, she produced this as her jazzed up side salad:

Finally, because this is how we roll, we also made a salad for Douglas, our hamster. So much for avoiding food prep for a meal.

I don’t know what to think here. I will give them props for lowering the cost of a small drip coffee from a extortionist-priced $5 to $4. I was also told that there is now sometimes a rice krispy treat available so as to have one gluten free pastry option, although it was not available yesterday. So perhaps they are trying their best, and maybe will be open to ongoing feedback, but there are a lot of glitches that need to be worked out and a lot of fine tuning to be done.

11 Likes

Your hamster is adorable. And I love your writing.

2 Likes

Sprout’s jazzed up salad looks VERY good! (Maybe send that to them to encourage them to really make a salad?)

And Douglas the Hamster is adorable!

1 Like

Yay, hamster got a snack! I’m sorry you’ve had such disappointing experiences, but good to note. Taking that one right off the list. When you can make a wedge salad look masterful and complex by comparison (“It’s just iceberg lettuce and a tomatoes!”), that is not a good salad. I do applaud that I didn’t see any brown and wilted bits, I guess…

2 Likes

At least Douglas looks happy!!

3 Likes

Winter break right around the corner; perhaps Hearth & Hug has an opening for a menu consultant?

3 Likes

Thanks, it’s fairly close to us, too, and we won’t be going anytime soon. And yes, adorable hamster! So dangerous that someone working at a bakery doesn’t know that AP flour is 100% wheat.

Did you see the Boston Globe review a few days ago? I’m glad I read yours. The opening sentence is brilliant! That tiny bowl of lettuce only is the “seasonal salad” for $15 on the menu?

https://www.bostonglobe.com/2025/12/09/lifestyle/natalie-hug-somerville-bakery/#comment-209474846

Oh well.

Argh- paywall! Are you willing to cut and paste the Globe review?

No, that was the $6 side salad that was lettuce only. There was some uncertainty about what was in the seasonal salad for $16, but it did not appear to include a protein (grilled chicken, for example, would have put it at a reasonable price point compared to the sandwiches) and the sprout wasn’t enthusiastic about what was reported to be in it. (If you only have one seasonal salad, why not list the ingredients right by the register on the specials board?)

Isn’t Douglas a cutie? Hamsters are under-rated as pets. He gets his own tiny bowl of salad odds and ends most days.

4 Likes

Somerville’s Hearth & Hug Bakery is the warm embrace we all need in December

By Kara Baskin Globe Correspondent,Updated December 11, 2025, 2:15 p.m.

3

The breakfast grilled cheese sandwich made with cheddar, gruyere, and gouda, bacon tomato jam, arugula, and an over-easy egg on classic sourdough at Hearth & Hug Bakery in Somerville.JOSH REYNOLDS FOR THE BOSTON GLOBE/Josh Reynolds for The Boston Globe

Where to: Hearth & Hug Bakery, outside Somerville’s Davis Square.

Why: For ginormous pastries, savory breakfasts, sandwiches, and coffee in folksy surroundings. Browse the square-dancing fliers in the windows while listening to Crosby, Stills & Nash harmonize on “Our House.”

Signage outside the Hearth & Hug Bakery in Somerville on Dec. 10.JOSH REYNOLDS FOR THE BOSTON GLOBE/Josh Reynolds for The Boston Globe

The backstory: Natalie Hug — yep, that’s her real name — came to Boston from Northern California to study culinary management at the now-closed Newbury College.

“I’ve wanted to have a chocolate factory ever since I was very young and had ‘Charlie and the Chocolate Factory’ read to me. I had a dream of being a candy-maker. I would do candy-making for my science fair projects,” she says.

Related

Chef-inspired classics at a city seafood shackThis year’s best cookbooks for holiday giving

In middle school, Hug expanded into baking.

“I was known for being the person who always had food, who always had cookies, who always had something to share with people,” she says.

That never changed. After college, Hug landed a bakery position at Formaggio Kitchen before striking out on her own, first with a stall at Boston Public Market. Now, she’s in the former Q’s Nuts space outside Davis Square, a sunny spot with quirky Somervillian notices on the wall (in addition to the square-dancing ad, there’s one for a wax-sculpture-and-bronze-casting class and another for a new mom’s club at local breweries). Steely Dan plays in the background until “Déjà Vu” warbles on.

Lines have been long since opening day in mid-November, Hug says, and they are again on this blustery midweek morning.

“We did our best to put ourselves out there in the community. We didn’t do a ton of big advertising or anything like that. We just did our best to communicate to people around us in the neighborhood. I’m a Somerville resident, so I was trying to tell people I knew. The community just showed up for us, which was awesome,” Hug says.

Owner Natalie Hug photographed at Hearth & Hug Bakery in Somerville on Dec. 10.JOSH REYNOLDS FOR THE BOSTON GLOBE/Josh Reynolds for The Boston Globe

What to eat: Hubcap-size breakfast treats, including a chocolate-filled, ultra-flaky homemade pop tart and a Danish piped with ricotta and roasted squash (ask for it warmed), plus Hug’s signature golfeados — a sweet, slightly salty Venezuelan pastry that tastes like a cheesy, sugar-cane-scented pillow.

There’s also deviled egg toast ($15) on homemade sourdough: Hard-boiled eggs are creamed to perfection, dotted with smoky crisped shallots and tangled in a lot of arugula. Next time, I’m saving room for the three-cheese breakfast sandwich, a grilled stack of cheddar, gruyere, and gouda with bacon-tomato jam and an over-easy egg ($12). Gooey! Hug tells me it’s their most popular item.

For lunch, find tea sandwiches for $10 and up (smoked salmon; ham, honey, and whipped butter), plus fun stuff like French fries ($6), stuffed sopapillas ($18), and Hug’s favorite sesame chicken sandwich with cabbage and carrots on sourdough ($16). All breads are baked in-house.

A variety of baked goods on display in the bakery case at the recently opened Hearth & Hug Bakery.JOSH REYNOLDS FOR THE BOSTON GLOBE/Josh Reynolds for The Boston Globe

What to drink: Espresso beans come from Ipswich’s Little Wolf Coffee Roasters; drip coffee comes from Lowell’s Tiny Arms. You’ll find the usual suspects here: mochas, lattes, flat whites. There are also offbeat seasonal specials, like cranberry mochas, juniper sage espresso tonics, and a brown-butter molasses latte.

The takeaway: A cozy spot that really does feel like a hug. All that’s missing are two cats in the yard and a roaring fireplace.

Hearth & Hug Bakery, 349 Highland Ave., Somerville, 617-209-9354, www.hearthandhugbakery.com