GOOD EATS NYC 2024 (A Blanket Thread)

ULIVO

I’ve walked by this place so many times, but first time eating there, and only because we needed a group to be accommodated at the last minute and they could. Turns out they are very popular for groups – the whole back seemed filled with groups of various sizes. It’s a nice room, and a central location, so not that surprising.

Food varied from very good to so-so.

Fried zucchini came out as skinny sticks, light and crisp, with plenty of lemon to squeeze over, just perfect. Fritto misto was a mixed bag, with awful shrimp, but well-fried fish – that was in oddly large pieces (calamari was meh). And a very good caprese salad despite the season. Generous, shareable portions.

The pastas were a mixed bag – trapanese pesto was fine, but the busiate was overcooked, cannelloni were very good (though I found the short rib ragu a bit salty), squid ink tagliatelle was the weak link of the night, and a daily special beet and truffle ravioli was the surprise winner, absolutely delicious.

Desserts were okay, but I’m not usually a dessert person anyway – decent tiramisu, a good chocolate budino, and a perplexing special that was supposed to be a napoleon of puff pastry and custard, but was chunks of puff pastry with pastry cream that was hard to eat (especially to share).

Very nice service – friendly, attentive, and patient, despite a full room.

I’d go back with a group again, they made it so easy, and the food was more good than not.

2 Likes

Yup.

I like Ulivo. Sort of became friends with Manu (Emanuel Concas) the chef over the years, since the Mercato, Hell’s Kitchen days. For a place so easy to get a table, the food is more than adequate. Good drinks, the pizzas are underrated. The Busiate is usually a must for us. You have Sardinian and Sicilian dishes not easily found here. And worth noting the free lentil dip with bread, while the rest of the city charges for everything these days.


2 Likes

We saw pizza on a few tables and almost got one to start, but someone said “no pizza” (why do I know these people, you;re wondering? Me too.)

But nice catch on the lentil dip – it was lovely. So savory that I stopped our vegetarian from digging in before we confirmed that there were no anchovies in it! (The bread wasn’t good enough for that dip, though.)

1 Like

Looking up how Michelin describes Bib themselves:

our best value for money restaurants – offering a three course meal at a reasonable price

The price limit for Bib Gourmand consideration varies from country to country, depending on the cost of living

What Bib restaurants do have in common is their simpler style of cooking, which is recognisable and easy-to-eat

I think the last one is what actually confused me about Bungalow (and several of the others) even aside from the price — it’s extremely fussy and deliberately dressed up, quite the opposite of “simpler style” (the only time I’ve looked at Bib before now was in Hing Kong, where inexpensive wantan mien, roast meats, and dim sum places are on the list).

@fooddabbler
Re your (very funny) goat curry rant, Imli (now rebranded Lungi) which is a few blocks up from Bloomies had several goat curries (and biryani) on the menu.

Lungi still has a couple, but also a surprising showing of paya / trotters. So perhaps it’s even more inane that Priya Krishna selected a paneer dish to showcase from a region that does not count paneer as a native ingredient, while ignoring all the seafood, never mind the beef that’s not often encountered at Indian restaurants in nyc or elsewhere,

(It is possible she doesn’t eat much offal given vegetarian parentage, and maybe not even goat — should a NYT food critic be required to have an expansive / inclusive palate? :thinking:)

1 Like

That is terrible news about Thrillist. Their general food reviews weren’t always reliable, but for barbecue their annual best-of lists were outstanding.

1 Like

Have you been to Corima?

Toni and I have reservations for early January, but they’re sort of a backup plan. We have friends who aren’t able to commit to whether they’ll be available that evening. The reservations can be canceled, so if there are reasons to avoid the place we can.

We’ll be eating off the ala carte menu since they refuse to make any adjustments to the tasting menu, ruing it out for the lactose intolerant (me). I am a little intimidated by the cost of the menu, but won’t be able to resist the $9 tortilla, probably.

Kimika, 'cause the mister wanted a special uni dish for our “day we met” anniversary, and Kimika serves an uni pasta. This is the place to take your heavy eater friends, because the food is CRAZY RICH. We ordered a “kill me with carbs” array of food - the uni pasta, the soy butter bigoli, the uni toast, and French fries. I can barely move, now. It was all good, but this is definitely a candidate for share everything. I feel like I’m about 74% butter.

5 Likes

The “Where To Eaties” awards were a good light read

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/19/dining/the-first-ever-where-to-eaties-awards.html

when a couple of the recs are “where to take your parents” I know they are definitely writing for tik-tok world. A departure for the nyt. “Eaties” is not part of my vocabulary yet either, Im not sure what this is really about except that its not serious!

Yes, and that’s a positive :joy:

We just had a very good dinner at FAUN on Vanderbilt Ave in {Prospect Heights} [Brooklyn] just up the street Their small menu has super diversity with plenty for vegetarians and pescatarians, good meat and pastas and a serious selection of wine .
https://www.faun.nyc/menu
Jim and I enjoyed sharing their papardelle with beef ragu and whipped ricotta, as well as the gigantic roasted skate wing in a buttery chile-scented sauce with hazelnuts, yellow raisins, capers etc.


A side of roasted broccolini and the focaccia (a BIG piece, enough for 4 for $4 with olive oil, along with a $7 plate of whipped ricotta were ample and delicious, and our veggie friends very much liked their roasted caraflex cabbage (its half of a long yellow cabbage, charred) and dressed with sesame hollandaise and other tasty stuff

and malfaldine pasta in a green pesto with stracciatella cheese. Jim wanted the duck and I thought the mussels on offer looked great so we will be back soon. A Pinot Blanc from Alsace was very good . $71 was not exactly a bargain, but hey.

5 Likes

I have not, but someone just wrote about the tasting menu

1 Like

Here? I thought I’d searched for that.

Different thread.

Terrific meal at Leon’s, Nick Anderer and wife Natalie Johnson latest after Anton’s. One month old, over a year in the making, open all day. I went for Brunch before a show (Titanique, 6 thumbs up) but had no interest in the Brunch items. Italian with an Egyptian twist (Natalie’s heritage)

Salame Rosa - Excellent! Fatty not quite Mortadella
Bresaola - Also good. Aromatic, nice aftertaste
Falafel - Egyptian style with Fave Beans, wont convert any falafel freaks but quite good
Eggplant Boulettes - Airy Eggplant meatballs that look like Falafel, with creamy tomato sauce. One of the better dishes
Tuna Carpaccio - Pretty much what you’d expect. With capers and fried shallots.
Busiate, Pistou Rouge & Sicilian Almonds - Good. Simple but good.
Fettuccine with Bolognese al Pastore - Better. Rich, meaty, mostly lamb I think.
Need to come back for the chicken Baharat. If you tried his chicken at Maialino, Marta an Anton’s, you’d know.






4 Likes

That’s pretty heavy-handed with the bolognese :open_mouth:

We had a passionate discussion on whether we should ask for more bread to properly “scarpetta” that thing. We decided against, and still somehow cleaned it.

Syko in Windsor Terrace, Brooklyn now has a spot, Dukan Syko, in the old J&H Farm bodega location for a few groceries, homemade kimchi, homemade Syrian dips like muhammara, and perhaps most notably, fresh-made manoushe. I haven’t had a chance to try it yet. I don’t know if anybody else is making manoushe in Brooklyn. I visited a friend in Rockville MD recently and loved Z&Z Manoushe, and it seems quite successful, so if Syko is getting in on that action, then good for them! These don’t look quite as visually appealing though.


By contrast, two of Z&Z’s offerings in Maryland:

7 Likes