Tiarrés, a breakfast spot on Bayview south of Eglinton, has an Afternoon Tea available. I haven’t been and I don’t know how much it costs. Tiarrés calls their tea with scones and party sandwiches a High Tea, but we all know the tea with scones, party sandwiches and fancies/petit fours is Afternoon Tea, and the meal served at supper time is the Tea or High Tea, a meal with tea, but without the scones, party sandwiches and fancies.
Also, apparently, the Royal York’s Clockwork does a nice job catering to vegetarians for Afternoon Tea, putting more effort into the vegetarian tea sandwiches. The price doesn’t seem to be listed on the site. My friend’s Afternoon Tea at the Royal York cost around $95 pp before tax, if I remember correctly.