Toros is where we ended up! Thank you 
The folks at the sweet shop also suggested Yakanoz as an alternative, FYI for others.
The latter is more fast casual looking, so we picked Toros.
Food was delicious, especially the Sigara, Manti and Adana. Apparently they don’t serve some things in the evening, and they had run out of others.
Highly recommend the baklava at Antep (the green ones made with pistachio paste are the closest I’ve had to Gulluoglu.
We also had a fun jaunt through Istanbul Food Market, which reminded me of a smaller Patel brothers but for Turkish ingredients (and blew my friend’s mind, plus points). We picked up some of their ready dishes like boreks, stuffed grape leaves, and bulgur kofte. All met with immediate approval as we broke into them pretty much on the spot 
