I mostly get the pizza slices, the foccaccia, the pastries, pesto, pasta sauce, packaged imported goods, the panini from the Gran Caffe on the ground floor, pastries, tortes and the ready-to-eat salads and thebheat-at-home refrigerated meals (eggplant parm, pastas, chicken valdostana, gnocchis).
The salads from the pizza and pasta restaurant aren’t that great. I liked one dine-in seafood pasta in 2020, but found one take-out pasta from the pizza and pasta restaurant mediocre last year.
In the Gran Caffe, I also get coffee, and this time of year they have crema di caffe, which is a frozen sweet coffee cream, which is nice (Sud Forno also has a Crema di Caffe now). I also enjoyed the cherry granita from the Gran Caffe last month.
I have often posted some photos of my Eataly take-out on the takeout thread.
I have been to the Eataly in New York near 23rd St.
I didn’t bother visiting the Eataly in Munich, Rome or London pre-pandemic.
It is essentially a grocery store for me. I don’t got there for the dine-in restaurants.
It also was 3 blocks from where I lived, and open until 10 pm, so it has been the place for a healthier takeout meal over the last 3 1/2 years. Most restaurants in Yorkville and the Annex don’t offer take-out after 9 pm.
Now that I don’t live close to Eataly, I will be getting more upscale Italian take-out from Barocco x Nino, which is a venture by Barocco coffee and Nino D’Aversa Bakery, and Alimentari on Roncesvalles.
The heat at home lasagna from Barocco x Nino was very good (Tavola on the label, prob the same at the other Nino D’Aversa locations) was a little less rich than Eataly’s refrigerated lasagna. Very good. Barocco x Nino have around 5 Roman pizzas by the slice during the day. I tried the Calabrese slice and Artichoke slice last week.
Alimentari has good meatballs and good eggplant parm. I haven’t tried other food from their hot table yet.
Sadly, Centro Formaggio e Trattoria closed on St Clair W. In terms of hot tables, it looks like Eataly, Alimentari and Barocco x Nino, along with the old school bakeries like Tre Mari, San Remo, various other bakeries in Scarborough and Mississauga, are the main places for Italian hot tables now.