Happy birthday! 25 is the new 21, they say 
Adding my 2c from afar 
For myself, I go back & forth on fancy setting vs food that excites me, and usually end up closer to the latter but maybe with a slightly nicer ambience.
Celeste seemed too casual to suggest for this, but their newer place La Royal has a different ambience and the menu might suit. On my list for soon.
On a similar note, Juliet is in a new location and was supposed to restart their prix fixe menus this month (maybe someone here has visited since the move and can opine).
The menu at Facchia Bruta looks lovely, but again the setting may be too casual. (Fwiw I enjoy Toro, and tapas there or elsewhere could make for a fun birthday celebration given the energy of small plates, tasty drinks, and general vibe.)
Linking your earlier thread here as well - some of those recs might also work for dinner.
