GOOD EATS NYC 2025 — Where & what did you eat?

A pity that you seem to have been underwhelmed by the food. What did the carnivores among you think? Did anybody have the trotters?

Anglo-Indian food is an interesting sub-cuisine, and quite tasty if done well. In my youth my parents booked bungalows in the summers at this or that anglo- resort (restricted in the past to British guests), and I’d always look forward to the food: mutton stews thickened with semolina, as white as the colonizers, but spiked with black peppercorns and green chillies, breaded fish cutlets, the fish liberally spiced, etc. And, of course, custards and suchlike to follow.

I remember there was shepherd’s pie (or more accurately, goatherd’s pie), duck, sea bream and chicken croquettes on the table (I’ve forgotten one of the entrees). Perhaps my companions will weigh in with their opinions.

I think it was probably done well. It’s just generally not to my taste.

Pippali closed

I think it’s pretty well established that we really like Indian Table & go regularly (monthly, maybe a little more). We’ve also been part of most of the Restaurant Week dinners (with and without other HO posters). And my wife and I are most definitely carnivores, with me being more of the “whole animal” variety.
I’m glad fooddabbler weighed in on this discussion of Indian Table’s RW offering, as I really needed some more context.
At any rate, I come away from the meal happy that I got to try some very unfamiliar dishes based on a very unfamiliar to me part of Indian culture, but wouldn’t rush to order most of what we had over what is offered on the regular Goa-centric menu. I’d like to hear what ninkat thought, as she ordered the duck app and the fish main course, but my wife’s goat Shepherd’s Pie was well made but just not something either of us (yes, I helped) thought (as small_h says) was to our taste. My osso bucco style lamb was excellent, covered with a brown gravy that was rich and tasty - a winner. Given that small_h seems to have liked her “Egg Currey”, that’s 2 (or 3 if ninkat liked the fish?) of the mains that were enjoyed. As for the apps, the cauliflower dish was, again, well prepared, but I prefer their usual preparation for my dose of cauliflower. The shrimp cutlets were more like crab cakes made with pieces of shrimp and were, in my opinion, just okay. I thought that the “minced chicken croquettes seasoned w/ special spices” were quite good and I’d order them again. I prefer lentil based Dahl to the chick pea version served & I thought both the rice and paratha were excellent. And, no – no one ordered the trotters.
Overall, glad I tried it and glad they keep offering things that allow me to expand my idea of what “Indian food” is. And we may even go back before this ends to try some other things. It’s nice to have a talented kitchen that is interested in pursuing various avenues and challenging itself. Especially since its regular menu is so good and is always there.

1 Like

Yeah. Hadn’t gotten back recently and didn’t ask Samir about it when we were at Indian Table. Pippali is where we first met him years ago when he was front of house there.

1 Like

thanks to everybody for the reports. hopefully we will get over before it closes - everybody’s opinions are sure helpful!

That’s very true. If I get a chance I’ll pop over to see if that anglo- food matches what I’d had in my youth, but the logistics of my two-city existence make that a remote chance. Oddly, I had a small window last Tuesday when I could have been there. I was with friends who had a car, and we discussed it, but we chose Levant (upthread) instead.

This goatherd’s pie of which you speak was another regular on the resort-anglo- food of my earlier years, and I used to quite like it. But, you all must understand that regular Indian food was not a big deal for me then. It was just food.

Freshly made chapatis served hot off the tava (pan)? Routine, night after boring night.

Dal of different types every night? Yawn.

Vegetables of various kinds – leafy, starchy, cruciferous – cooked in myriad ways? Gimme a break.

Fish, mutton, chicken – always on-the-bone – always well-spiced, and always different night after night. I’m snoring.

Freshly made dahi (yoghurt)? Kill me now.

[ETA: And every frickin’ meal had one each of the above, and in some cases two.]

It was in that context that I, ungrateful wretch that I was back then (now I’m just a wretch), embraced anglo- food. It was different.

There was a fancyish restaurant at the top of Malabar Hill in Bombay, overlooking the bay (and the lights of the “Queen’s Necklace” that glittered along the drive around the bay – Marine Drive) that was one of our go-to places for food that was a mish-mash of real Indian – although a weak version – and anglo-. To prove the callowness of my credentials, I’d determinedly order “ham and eggs” there, and for dinner no less. They were just different.

1 Like

A pity. I thought they were decent. I last had their food in October ('24), and the mutton curry was pretty good as were their kebabs.

1 Like

I was surprised that they chose Anglo-Indian over all the types of regional Indian.

Did they instruct you on how to open it up and eat it? (Artichoke is a good comparison.) I love moringa, but it’s not often encountered outside the home (except in sambhar).

Beyond sucking on it? That’s been my modus operandi, but I’m willing to learn.

I was looking at the menu more closely, and a lot of it isn’t anglo, just preparations from different christian communities around the country.

For eg Ball Curry is kofta curry, which could be Keralite or Goan depending on the spicing (and should always be served with coconut rice). Pepper fry is Kerala beef pepper fry, with or without coconut. Molly’s fish is Kerala fish moilee. Dak bungalow chicken curry is a generic (but tasty) curry served at circuit houses aka government guest houses, not an Anglo prep but a simplified Indian one. Hard to go wrong with any of those.

They usually do a good job with whatever they choose to explore.

I’ve had it (in Kerala), so I knew.

1 Like

“Sucking” was not even something I had considered (there’s not really anything suck-able in the pod other than a few seeds, because the pulp is attached to the sides).

(1) open up a bite-sized piece of drumstick (it splits naturally into thirds) and use your teeth to remove the pulp from each piece, as with an artichoke petal

(2) chew a whole bite-sized piece (like sugarcane) and discard the mouthful of fiber left after (I learned quite late in life that some people apparently don’t have the patience for (1) – as also apparently for pomegranate arils)

This makes me sad. Everything tasted legit. I hope they resurface as something new.

1 Like

It’s more like scraping.

Yes, I spoke loosely. It’s a scrape.

I had fish, not breaded, and I really enjoyed it. Also, started with duck (also a fried thing), looked somewhat like a croque monsieur. I am not familiar with this type of Indian food. Probably wouldn’t go out of my way for it, but the duck sandwich thing was also yummy. I can see this food being approachable for kids too. I wasn’t wowed by my dessert (the one described as like French toast, but looked more like pancakes to me), but the ginger one I had a bite of was surprisingly good and not too sweet.

@fooddabbler, I had to teach myself to find the food value in drumsticks and Saregama has it exactly - a little messy but you run the pieces of pod between your teeth to scrape off the tasty pulp. You chew as long as there is flavor/juice there and discard the remains as gracefully as possible.

Haven’t been to Oceana in 10 years. They used to have a very extensive menu, with many different fish with your choice of sauce, and a number of composed dishes as well. It was great, but now the menu (like so many others) is quite limited and not particularly interesting. If I’m going to spend that much I expect better.

Recent finds:

Oiji Mi. Not as pricey as one might expect for the quality. I posted about it on HO and on my blog.

Santi. I expected a lot from Michael White and was not disappointed. Everything was wonderful. I will be writing more about it shortly.

Thai Villa. Excellent, prices higher than most Thai places, but of superior quality, and big portions so we take half home for another meal.

Other favorites:

Ferdi. Nice prix-fixe for $38.75 Sunday to Thursday (closed Tuesday).

Le Zie. Superb food and a large menu with many specials.

Elmo. An old favorite that had gone downhill but has made a great comeback.

Baazi. Best Indian I’ve found.

Casa Mono. Best tapas anywhere.

Gnocco. Reliably good and reasonable.

Ama on Downing. Asian-influenced small plates and raw bar.

I’ve written about several of these on my blog:

4 Likes